Much has been made of Nikole Hannah-Jones’s New York Times piece on the challenges of navigating New York’s public school system for her own child.
Among those using Jones’s piece to lob attacks at teachers and public schools is The Atlantic’s Idrees Kahloon.
Kahloon suggests school leaders are failing and teachers lack commitment to their work:
The goal was laudable, but the failure to achieve it suggests that even committed parents cannot, on their own, overcome all of the factors that keep a troubled school from becoming an excellent one—a dearth of leadership, the commitment of its teachers, and the behavior of other students.
He then argues in favor of charter schools:
Urban charter schools run by experienced school networks, and tightly regulated by watchful districts, have proved again and again to be capable of improving educational outcomes for exactly the kinds of children—poor, minority, those with special needs—that the traditional public-school system struggles with.
And can’t resist adding that it is teachers - and their unions - that stand in the way of real reform:
Advocates for traditional public schools, especially their unionized teaching force, object to charters because dollars follow students out their classroom doors.
And, well, Kahloon is wrong. On all fronts.
I’ll refer first to a succinct analysis of the Jones piece offered in Accountabaloney:
. . . when responsibility for a child’s education is privatized, poor outcomes increasingly become the responsibility of the individual parent—not the school, the system, or society at large. When the debate becomes more about whether individual parents made the right decision to escape an underperforming school than about why society continues to tolerate substandard schools for children with the fewest options, education will become every family for itself—and the privatization project will have succeeded to the detriment of society as whole.
The problems Jones highlights and Kahloon laments are systemic - and deeper than the education system. They are societal problems - the moral failing of continuing to allow the persistence of poverty.
Kahloon references charter schools, but then mentions a very specific set of circumstances.
This ignores that the vast majority of charter schools perform no better than public schools, and many perform worse. Which means resources for traditional public schools are used on an experiment that yields a very disappointing return on investment.
Stephen Dyer’s recent piece about Ohio charter schools notes:
In the 2024-2025 school year, there were 340 Ohio charter schools in operation. And 114 of them ended up on the CSI list. Nearly 6 in 10 were on that list since 2018.
Dyer notes that about 1 in 3 charter schools make the lowest-performing list. By contrast, about 5% of public schools make the list.
Ohio’s charter “reform” costs $1.6 billion and funds a lot of schools among the lowest-performing in the state.
In Tennessee, the charter-focused Achievement School District intervention - designed to boost academic outcomes in areas with historically low-performing schools - failed miserably.
The district’s first Superintendent said this upon leaving:
In his email early Friday, Barbic offered a dim prognosis on that pioneering approach. “As a charter school founder, I did my fair share of chest pounding over great results,” he wrote. “I’ve learned that getting these same results in a zoned neighborhood school environment is much harder.”
The results did not get better after Barbic left:
The state has failed miserably in running schools and the state should not be in the business of being a school district, period,” State Rep. Antonio Parkinson said. “The Achievement School District came in and aggressively divided these communities and took over these schools, and then they performed worse than the schools they actually took over.”
The latest data from the Department of Education shows each of the four schools report less than five percent of students performing at grade level. ASD as a whole reports just 4.5 percent of students performing at grade level.
And yes, the performance rate of students in the charter-focused ASD lagged well below the performance of similar students in district schools.
Persistent poverty is tough to overcome by schools alone - health care, food security, housing - all must be addressed to move the needle on education outcomes.
As for the teachers and their unions, Kahloon suggests that a big part of the problem is teachers who are not committed to serving their students in schools with a significant low-income population.
This tells me Kahloon has spent little time in such environments.
Showing up every single day in some of the most challenging educational environments and meeting students where they are is a commitment. And, as the ASD’s Barbic notes, no matter how committed, no matter how many hours before and after school worked, that commitment alone may not move the needle on overall academic performance. It may mean children are seen and heard and offered some semblance of stability - but that without addressing the core problem of economic inequality - will likely do little to make test scores go up.
Kahloon also notes that Mississippi has gotten some encouraging results over a 13-year period of reform. First, this reform and the attendant results required commitment over more than a decade. Second, it required investment - Mississippi, once last in investment in schools, is now 45th. The state spends $2000 more per student now than neighboring Tennessee.
Attacking teachers and boosting charters won’t improve results in America’s schools.
Addressing poverty, health care, housing, and jobs will - but that’s a tougher set of challenges. Better (and easier) to attack unions and appear as a reasonable policy moderate than be dubbed a radical voice that demands access to economic justice for all.


